Report: Simon Benoit Trade Rumors Heat Up as Defender Hits Trade Board
A surprise name has entered the conversation. With the deadline looming, insider Chris Johnston reports that the Maple Leafs may look to capitalize on the value of their physical defenseman.
TSP Rumor Tracker: Jan 19 Update
We are tracking a new development from TSN Insider Chris Johnston regarding the Maple Leafs’ blue line assets.
- The Player: Simon Benoit (#2).
- Trade Board Rank: Debuts at #19 on CJ’s Big Board.
- The Logic: Cap-friendly contract ($1.35M) provides high value to contenders.
- Status: “Making the rounds” in league talks.
The Simon Benoit trade rumors caught many in Leafs Nation off guard on Monday morning. Known as a fan favorite for his physicality and “Milkman” persona, Benoit has been a staple of the bottom pair. However, his very reliability—and his contract—may be exactly what makes him a prime trade chip.
Johnston: Benoit Debuts at #19
According to a new report from The Athletic, Simon Benoit has officially entered the chat. In his latest Trade Board update, Chris Johnston placed the Leafs defenseman at #19, citing his contract status as the primary driver of interest.
“[Simon] Benoit represents a player who could bring back some value with a cap-friendly contract that runs through next season. That’s the main reason his name has recently started making the rounds.” — Chris Johnston, The Athletic
This is a significant shift. While most trade chatter has focused on Toronto acquiring talent (like Dougie Hamilton), this report suggests GM Brad Treliving is also exploring the seller’s market to rebalance his assets.
The Contract: $1.35M Gold
Why would teams want Benoit? Cost certainty. Finding a physical, everyday NHL defenseman for under $1.5 million is a luxury.
Benoit is currently in the second year of a 3-year extension he signed in March 2024. His deal carries an AAV of just $1.35 million and does not expire until the summer of 2027. For a contending team needing grit on the third pair, Benoit offers a solution not just for this playoff run, but for the entire 2026-27 season as well.
Why Trade Him?
The decision to move Benoit likely stems from a numbers game. If the Maple Leafs are serious about acquiring a top-tier defenseman like Dougie Hamilton, someone has to move out.
With Benoit’s value at an all-time high due to his contract efficiency, Treliving may view this as the perfect “sell high” opportunity. Moving Benoit could clear a roster spot for a bigger acquisition while recouping a mid-round draft pick or a prospect to replenish the cupboard.
TSP Analysis: The Upgrade Path
Trading Benoit is risky—he provides the snot and sandpaper this team often lacks. However, if trading him allows the Leafs to upgrade to a legitimate Top-4 puck mover, it is a sacrifice Treliving has to make.
If the Leafs land a big fish, Benoit becomes the #7 defenseman. Trading him now maximizes his asset value rather than letting him sit in the press box.
For the full Trade Board breakdown, visit The Athletic.